Page 2 of 2

Re: A Hickory ID Request

PostPosted: Wed Feb 08, 2017 3:16 pm
by ElijahW
Josh & Brian,

Thanks.  To keep from influencing the results, I'll hold off on giving my opinion just yet.  I really only have strong confidence about tree #4.  Traveling north of Syracuse, the only native hickories you're likely to encounter will be Bitternut and Shagbark, and even those species fade quickly once you get into the mountains.  This is unfamiliar territory for me, and I value greatly your expertise.  I'm excited to verify what these species are in a few months.


Re: A Hickory ID Request

PostPosted: Wed Feb 08, 2017 4:50 pm
by bbeduhn
I forgot how far north you are. Hickories do tend to look a bit different at northern latitudes than at southern latitudes. #1 doesn't look much like southern mockernuts but it does have a ropey appearance in its bark. #4 is a little perplexing. Fortunately, the nuts make them easy to tell apart with the exception of red and pignut. Mockernut has thick twigs. Your #4 is likely bitternut like you surmised. It's usually smoother barked but can look a little pignutty with squared off edges.

These two links cover hikories quite well. ... kories.htm ... PB1810.pdf

Re: A Hickory ID Request

PostPosted: Tue Oct 17, 2017 7:01 pm
by ElijahW

I have a number of updates to my earlier questions in this thread.  Firstly, on the topic of Hickory species present at Oakwood Cemetery, I asked Dr. Leopold in person a few months ago and received some helpful answers.  Mockernut is not found on the property, and the tree I posted photos of is Red, as Will surmised.  The tree I thought to be Mockernut was, in fact, Pignut.  

In regard to the numbered photos, I've learned the following:

1.)  #1 is not Mockernut.  The nuts I found were thin-shelled and lacked sharp ridges, which rules out Mockernut and Bitternut.  All leaves I found had 5 leaflets, which suggests, but does not prove, Pignut.

2.)  #2:  I haven't gotten back to this tree, but I think Red makes the most sense.

3.)  #3 actually fell down a few weeks ago, and I was able to see a lot of the canopy-level leaves up close.  All had 5 leaflets; however, I didn't find any nuts that I could reach, and what was on the forest floor I wasn't certain which tree it came from.  On this tree I'm leaning toward Pignut, but Red certainly was not ruled out.

4.)  #4 is Bitternut.  This was kind of a wildcard I threw in the mix, but already knew the answer.